Negative Confirmation Overview, Types, When to Use

If an individual or business entity is selected for an audit by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the taxpayer must produce records to affirm the information listed on the selected tax returns. The audit might include a positive confirmation request for all sources of income, verification of applicable deductions taken, and proof of claimed gains or losses. Fn 3 The need to maintain control does not preclude the use of internal auditors in the confirmation process.

  1. Have you ever had a “gut feeling” and stuck with it, even when confronted with evidence it was wrong?
  2. The new standard and conforming amendments will take effect for audits of financial statements for fiscal years ending on or after June 15, 2025.
  3. The letter asks the customers to respond to the auditor only if they find a discrepancy between their records and the information about the client company’s financial records that are supplied by the auditor.
  4. Upgrading to a paid membership gives you access to our extensive collection of plug-and-play Templates designed to power your performance—as well as CFI’s full course catalog and accredited Certification Programs.
  5. Whether the auditor uses positive or negative requests, SAS no. 67
    sanctions confirming individual transactions rather than entire
    account balances.

Financial institutions, public authorities, stores, restaurants, etc, are all part of the B2C category, where the primary customer base is the general public. Therefore, an auditor can assess the quality of the service provided by confirming with the customers. An auditor has several options for confirmation with external sources, but choosing the right one is an important task. Negative confirmation stands out for its efficiency in time and resource utilization.

These are just a few of the HR functions accounting firms must provide to stay competitive in the talent game. Now, if Quality Goods Co. does not respond, John takes that as confirmation that the $20,000 balance is correct. However, if Quality Goods Co. does respond and say, “Actually, we only owe $15,000,” then John has to investigate the discrepancy. 2 AS 2410, Related Parties, establishes requirements regarding the auditor’s evaluation of relationships and transactions between the company and its related parties. 1 Bill and hold sales are sales of merchandise that are billed to customers before delivery and are held by the entity for the customers. Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.

In a negative confirmation or negative consent communication situation, the company or entity sending the message only receives responses from “no” votes, as opposed to responses from everybody regardless of their opinion. The auditors scrutinize and evaluate a company’s financial health to find out whether the company in question reported the financial statements truly and fairly to interested parties. For the bank accounts, we usually use only positive confirmation as the risk of cash and bank is usually high, even their balances are low sometimes.

Create a free account to unlock this Template

It is important to assess managerial accounting assertions relative to generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), as well as to apply testing procedures that comply with generally accepted auditing standards (GAAS). Negative confirmation letters can be used in many types of business situations and are often used in the financial services industry. The purpose of the communication is to reduce the number of incoming responses an organization receives in reply to a letter sent to its client base.

Why Should An Auditor Use Negative Confirmations?

If the customer agrees with this number, it does not have to contact the auditor to confirm the supplied information. The auditor will then assume that the customer agrees with the information presented to it in the confirmation. Auditors also use positive confirmation letters to verify accounts payable and accounts receivable or companies. Accounts receivables represent money owed by a company’s customers for the sale of goods. Receivables and payables typically have payment terms of 30, 60, or 90 days—meaning a payment needs to be made within that time frame. Assuming audit risk remains constant, a decrease in material misstatement can increase detection risk.

those pronouncements and the publication in 1995 of the AICPA Auditing
Procedure Study Confirmation of Accounts Receivable ,
problems continued to crop up. In fact, the Institutes peer review
division (now the practice monitoring division) released a 1995 report
in the Practicing CPA citing fundamental violations of the
provisions of SAS no. 67. Even though the principle of confirmation is
long-standing, perhaps these peer review deficiencies reflect auditors
inadequate understanding of the requirements.

Accounts receivables are short-term assets and can be used by companies as collateral to obtain loans or financing from banks. As a result, it’s important that the receivables are audited to confirm that the sales were made as well as confirm that the funds from the sales are being collected on time. Upgrading to a paid membership gives you access to our extensive collection of plug-and-play Templates designed to power your performance—as well as CFI’s full course catalog and accredited Certification Programs. Over 1.8 million professionals use CFI to learn accounting, financial analysis, modeling and more.

Rather than resisting this kind of objective second opinion, I hope clinicians will embrace it. These cognitive biases may not be the reason U.S. life expectancy has stagnated for the past 20 years, but they stand in the way of positive change. The study illustrates how differently people can react to identical scenarios based on how the information is framed. Researchers have discovered that the human mind magnifies and experiences loss far more powerfully than positive gains. So, patients will consent to a chemotherapy regiment that has a 20% chance of cure but decline the same treatment when told it has 80% likelihood of failure. People with a serious medical problem commonly seek a benign explanation and find evidence to justify it.

Free Accounting Courses

See paragraph 8 of Auditing Standard No. 15, Audit Evidence, which discusses the reliability of audit evidence. In a positive confirmation approach, the auditor sends a confirmation request via any form of communication to the recipients, requiring them to express the accuracy of the accounts by a direct confirmation. For example, a confirmation letter tells a customer that the client company’s records at year-end show an ending accounts receivable balance for that customer of $500,000.

View the standard effective for audits of financial statements for fiscal years ending before June 15, 2025. The following new standard, AS 2310, The Auditor’s Use of Confirmation, will be effective for audits of financial statements for fiscal years ending on or after June 15, 2025. SAS no. 39, Audit Sampling , requires auditors to project
known misstatement results identified in a sample as likely
misstatements in the underlying population. The auditors then must
compare those likely misstatement amounts with the tolerable
misstatement amounts derived during audit planning to determine
whether sampling risk is acceptably low for the account balance. However, peer reviewers have found that auditors sometimes fail to
make this required projection and concomitant evaluation.

The Difference Between a Negative Confirmation and a Positive Confirmation

For this reason, most auditors prefer to use positive confirmations over negative confirmations, despite the additional cost. In a manufacturing or distribution company, for example, the
documentation includes examination of customer purchase orders (POs),
client invoice copies, shipping documents and third-party evidence of
delivery. Audit problems that might be found in such documentation
include, for example, evidence in customer POs of consignment
arrangements rather than sales, as well as shipping documents
indicating improper sales cutoffs. Additionally, auditors using the
examination of subsequent cash collections as a primary substantive
procedure might consider performing procedures to provide evidence
that the source of the payment was the customer. Detection risks are when an auditor fails to detect any misstatement that influences the financial statements. Control risks are when the company’s internal control fails to detect or prevent material misstatements.

It is measurably less expensive to distribute negative confirmations instead of positive confirmations, and therefore, more can be distributed for the same total cost. Negative confirmation is best applied in cases where the risk of material misstatement is low. The primary drivers of the risk of material misstatement are inherent risk and control risk. If acceptable audit risk is held equal, a decreased risk of material misstatement increases the detection risk of an auditor failing to identify material misstatements.

However, we usually only use negative confirmation to test the balances of accounts receivable or accounts payable. This is due to the risk of material misstatement for these two accounts are sometimes low. A KEY PROCESS
Properly applied confirmation procedures, in conjunction with
analytical procedures and related substantive alternative procedures,
provide significant evidence about most financial statement
assertions. This is particularly true for the existence and valuation
assertionstypically key assertions in the audit of the revenue and
collections cycle. Consequently, auditors should be especially careful
to apply confirmation procedures properly and be alert to possible
errors in their firms confirmation procedures.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome, a discount of -10% for all 1-year subscriptions (Gold, Diamond) with the following promo code: 10off
Refferlas offer: Get a free month when you refer a customer for a one-year subscription
Scroll to Top